peekgenticBook a call

Analysis · AI in business

The manufacturing labor shortage reaches the office: hiring vs. automating

The labor shortage talk is about the plant floor, but the office has its own version. Government data shows which desks are closest to retirement, which are shrinking, and how an owner can decide between filling a seat and automating part of it.

By Miguel GutierrezCo-founder, Peekgentic · Dallas
· 7 min read
Preview card: the manufacturing labor shortage reaches the office.
The office has its own version of the labor shortage, and it isn't the same at every desk.Peekgentic

In brief

Don't choose between hiring and automating for the whole office. Choose desk by desk. Government data shows bookkeeping, payroll and billing are the office jobs closest to retirement, and 40% of bookkeeping clerks are already 55 or older. Order desks skew much younger, so their case for automating is usually about volume and errors, not retirement. Automate the repeat typing, hire for judgment and customers, and write down what your veterans know before they leave.

  • The shortage is lumpy. Manufacturing openings hit 584,000 in September 2026 (preliminary), after job losses through much of 2025.
  • In the office, bookkeeping, payroll and billing are closest to retirement. 40% of bookkeeping clerks are 55 or older, against 23% of all workers.
  • BLS projects these office jobs will shrink about 5-6% by 2035 and still open by the thousands, all from replacing people who leave.
  • Decide desk by desk: automate repeat typing, hire for judgment and customers, and capture what veterans know first.
  • The payoff isn't automatic. UK firms estimate AI has raised productivity only about 0.5% in three years, so test with your own timed numbers.

The shortage everyone talks about is on the floor

When people say "manufacturing labor shortage," they usually mean welders, machinists and maintenance techs. The best known number comes from a 2024 study by the Manufacturing Institute and Deloitte. It projects that as many as 3.8 million manufacturing jobs could need filling from 2024 to 2033, and that 1.9 million could go unfilled if nothing changes. That's a projection from a group that speaks for the industry, and "as many as" is doing real work in that sentence.

The picture has also moved around. Manufacturing lost jobs for seven straight months through November 2025. Now it's growing again. The October 2026 jobs report shows 19,000 manufacturing jobs added, and 101,000 since a low in December 2025. Manufacturing job openings were 584,000 in September 2026, up from 389,000 a year earlier, though the newest figure is preliminary.

Worry has shifted as well. In early 2024, 65% of manufacturers in a NAM survey named attracting and retaining talent as their main challenge. In the first quarter of 2026, Manufacturing Dive's report on the same survey led with trade, healthcare costs and input costs. Here in Dallas-Fort Worth, BLS counted roughly 310,000 manufacturing jobs in mid-2026, about 1% fewer than a year before.

So this isn't a simple story of nobody to hire. It's lumpy. For an owner, the useful question is smaller: which seats in your building are at risk, and what should you do about each one?

The office has its own age problem, but not on every desk

Most of what gets written about this skips the office. BLS publishes employment by age for each occupation, and it shows a split most owners would not guess. We worked out the share of each group that's 55 or older.

Share of workers age 55 or older, by office job

U.S., all industries, 2025 annual averages. Our math from BLS counts. Order clerks is a small group (87,000), so read it loosely.

  1. Bookkeeping, accounting and auditing clerks40%
  2. Payroll and timekeeping clerks33%
  3. Billing and posting clerks30%
  4. All workers23%
  5. Production, planning and expediting clerks22%
  6. Shipping, receiving and inventory clerks21%
  7. Order clerks18%
  8. Customer service representatives18%

Source: BLS, Current Population Survey, employed persons by detailed occupation and age, 2025. Shares calculated by Peekgentic.

The back office is where the clock is running. The median bookkeeping clerk is 49.8, against 42.1 for all workers. The order desk looks different: the median order clerk is 35.5. These are national numbers across all industries, not a count of manufacturers. Your building may not match. But it's a good reason to look at finance and payroll first when you think about retirements, and to stop assuming the order desk has the same problem.

The back office has a retirement problem. The order desk has a volume problem. They need different answers.

The government expects these jobs to shrink and keep opening

Here's the part that looks like a contradiction. BLS projects each of these jobs will shrink over the decade, and also projects a lot of openings every year.

BLS outlook for office jobs, 2025 to 2035

JobProjected changeOpenings per yearMedian pay, May 2025
Bookkeeping, accounting and auditing clerksDown 6%144,100$50,670 a year
Material recording clerksDown 6%98,600$47,600 a year
General office clerksDown 6%249,000$21.64 an hour
Customer service representativesDown 5%289,500$21.53 an hour

Source: BLS Occupational Outlook Handbook, read through archived copies on Nov. 7, 2026. These are projections.

BLS says all of those openings come from replacing people who change jobs or leave the workforce, such as to retire. None come from growth. On bookkeeping, it gives the reason directly: software has automated many of the tasks, so the same work takes fewer people. It also expects the clerks who remain to do more analysis and less hand entry.

So plan on two things being true. People will keep leaving these seats, and fewer people will be working in the field. That doesn't prove you'll struggle to fill your next opening. We didn't find good public data on how long office seats stay open at mid-size manufacturers, so your own records are the better guide.

What an open seat costs, and what a filled one costs

Wages are not the full cost of a hire. BLS reports that benefits made up 30% of private employer pay costs in June 2026. That's an average across all private jobs, not clerks alone. As a rough guide, a clerk at the $50,670 median would cost about $72,000 a year with benefits, before recruiting and training.

That figure doesn't mean automation wins. A person does things software can't, and any system needs someone to own it. It just gives you a fair number to hold up against the work.

Now put that number next to the work. Here's a made-up example so you can see the math: 300 orders a week at 6 minutes each is 30 hours of typing and checking. If software drafts the orders and a person reviews them at 2 minutes each, that's 10 hours. Those are not benchmarks. Use your own timed numbers, because the answer depends on them.

Four desks, four different answers

The age data and the job data point to different moves at different desks. This is our reading, based on how these jobs usually work, so check it against your own office.

Bookkeeping and accounts payable. This desk is closest to retirement, and much of its value is in things nobody wrote down: which vendor always bills late, how a job gets coded, what the owner will and won't pay without a call. Software can read the invoice, match it to the PO and receipt and draft the entry. Keep payment approval and any change to a vendor's bank details with a person.

Payroll. It's older too, but your payroll system probably already does most of the math. The gap here is usually a backup person and written steps, not new AI. Mistakes land on your own people, so go slow.

The order desk. It skews younger, so retirement is less likely to be what forces the decision. The case for changing it is volume, errors and speed. Software can read emailed POs and draft the order. Keep pricing exceptions and new customers with a person.

Customer service. Much of the day is talking to people, and that's the part to protect. Routine order status emails can be drafted for review, which gives your reps more time for the customer who's upset.

A desk-by-desk way to decide

Hire, automate, or both

What you see at the deskLean towardWhy
Same few documents, high volume, mostly typingAutomate the typingThat's the part software does well, with a person approving
A veteran retiring in the next few yearsCapture first, then decideThe rules in their head are worth more than the keystrokes
Work is mostly calls, disputes and negotiatingHireCustomers and suppliers want a person who can make a call
Low volume, every item is differentHire or leave it aloneThere's too little repeat work to pay for a build
Volume is growing faster than headcount canBothAutomate the repeat work so the next hire does the harder work
Only one person knows how the job worksHire a backup and document itSoftware doesn't fix a single point of failure by itself

Where the other side has a point

Hiring may be the better growth move. Ramp and Revelio Labs studied more than 21,000 U.S. firms and found that companies investing heavily in AI grew headcount 10% over two years. So automating doesn't have to mean a smaller team. Ramp sells business software, though, and it notes those adopters were already larger and faster growing, which means AI may not be the cause.

The other evidence is less rosy. The Bank of England's November report says UK firms estimate AI has raised their productivity only about 0.5% over three years, and report close to zero effect on jobs overall. Its regional contacts do say AI is making firms less likely to hire or replace people, though not more likely to fire them. That's the UK, and it's firms' own estimates. But it's a useful check on anyone promising you a huge payoff.

Automation doesn't run itself. Someone has to review exceptions, handle new customers and notice when things drift. If you cut that person, you've moved the risk, not removed it. That's why we think a person should approve the work. And for a small office, a good hire can be simpler than any project.

What to do this month

  1. Map your office seats. List each desk, who sits there, and who might retire or leave within five years. Have this talk with care. Ask about plans, and don't guess from someone's age.
  2. Check your own hiring record. For the last few office hires, write down days open, what you paid, and how long until the person was fully up to speed.
  3. Time ten items at each busy desk. Orders, invoices, status emails. Count the weekly volume. Our list of signs an order desk needs help can tell you what to look for.
  4. Split each job into typing and judgment. Most desks have both. Look at them apart, and the choice usually gets easier.
  5. Write down what veterans know now. Start with the desks closest to retirement. Here's how to capture it. This pays off whether you hire, automate or do both.
  6. Tell your team the plan. People who fear for their jobs don't share their shortcuts. We looked at what the data says about AI and office jobs, and it may help with that talk.

Common questions

Is there really a labor shortage in manufacturing?

It depends on the job and the month. A 2024 Manufacturing Institute and Deloitte study projected as many as 1.9 million unfilled jobs through 2033 if nothing changes. Manufacturing lost jobs through much of 2025, but BLS shows 101,000 added since December 2025 and 584,000 openings in September 2026, a preliminary figure.

Does the shortage affect office jobs at manufacturers?

Some more than others. BLS data across all industries shows 40% of bookkeeping clerks are 55 or older, against 23% of all workers. Order clerks and customer service reps skew younger. Check your own building, since these are national numbers.

Why does BLS project both fewer jobs and many openings?

Because people keep leaving. BLS projects bookkeeping clerk jobs will fall 6% from 2025 to 2035, with about 144,100 openings a year. All of those openings come from replacing people who change jobs or leave the workforce.

Should I hire or automate my order desk?

Time ten orders and count your weekly volume. If most of the time is typing the same kinds of documents, automate that part and keep a person approving. If most of it is calls and judgment, hire.

What does an office hire really cost?

More than the wage. BLS reports benefits were 30% of private employer pay costs in June 2026. As a rough guide, a clerk at the $50,670 median would cost about $72,000 a year with benefits, before recruiting and training.

Will automating the office mean layoffs?

It doesn't have to. Many owners use it to avoid replacing a retiring person's typing, or to handle growth without adding seats. The Bank of England's contacts report AI making firms less likely to hire or replace people, but not more likely to fire them.

What should we do before a veteran employee retires?

Write down the rules they carry in their head: customer quirks, part number matches, who to call. Do it early and with them. It pays off whether you hire a replacement, automate part of the job or do both.

Sources

  1. Manufacturing Institute, Manufacturers Need as Many as 3.8 Million New Employees by 2033, April 3, 2024 (with Deloitte)
  2. BLS, The Employment Situation, October 2026
  3. BLS, JOLTS Table 1, job openings by industry, September 2026 (preliminary)
  4. BLS, Employed persons by detailed occupation and age, 2025 annual averages
  5. BLS, Occupational Outlook Handbook, Bookkeeping, Accounting, and Auditing Clerks
  6. BLS, Occupational Outlook Handbook, Material Recording Clerks
  7. BLS, Occupational Outlook Handbook, General Office Clerks
  8. BLS, Occupational Outlook Handbook, Customer Service Representatives
  9. BLS, Employer Costs for Employee Compensation, June 2026
  10. BLS, Dallas-Fort Worth-Arlington economy at a glance, 2026
  11. Plant Services, Latest BLS jobs report, Dec. 16, 2025
  12. Manufacturing Dive, Manufacturers upbeat about outlook despite economic headwinds: NAM, March 17, 2026
  13. Ramp Economics Lab, Companies hire more after AI adoption, June 30, 2026
  14. Bank of England, Monetary Policy Report, November 2026

More from Peekgentic

Published November 7, 2026 · Written by Miguel Gutierrez, Co-Founder, Peekgentic (Dallas, TX). Every statistic links its source.